Volume: 6 Issue: 2
Year: 2018, Page: 4-11,
Introduction: The diet-heart hypothesis, i.e. dietary cholesterol and saturated fats raise the serum cholesterol which in turn is a risk factor for coronary artery disease is prevalent since the 1950s. Over the years it had a major influence on the perspectives of nutritionists, medical researchers and the lay public. However, of late, the evidence base supporting the diet-heart hypothesis is being increasingly questioned. Besides retrieval and re-analysis of archival data from incomplete studies, study of internal documents of industry reveal that vested interests may have played a role in maintaining the diet-heart hypothesis. This brief review gives an overview of the evidence and conflicting views most of which fell by the wayside in the heady days of the diet-heart hypothesis. It puts forth the question whether there is a paradigm shift in the diet-heart hypothesis. Using the key-words "diet-heart hypothesis" an online literature search was made using PubMed, Scopus and Google Scholar. Standard texts on nutritional epidemiology and other writings on the subject were reviewed.
Keywords: Diet-heart hypothesis; evidence base; paradigm shift; coronary heart disease
1. Kahneman D. Thinking fast and slow. London. Penguin Random House UK. 2011.
2. Keys A. Atherosclerosis: A problem in newer public health. J Mt Sinai Hosp NY 1953; 20:118 – 39.
3. Konstantinov IE, Mejevoi N, Anichkov NM. Nikolai N. Anichkov and His Theory of Atherosclerosis. Texas Heart Institute Journal. 2006;33(4):417-423.
4. Gould R G. Lipid metabolism and atherosclerosis. Journal of Medicine 1951; 11: 2: 209 - 227.
5. Gould R G, Taylor C B, Hagerman J S, Warner I, Campbell D J. Cholesterol metabolism: 1. Effect of Dietary Cholesterol on the Synthesis of Cholesterol in Dog Tissue in Vitro. Journal of Biological Chemistry 1953; 201: 2: 519 – 528.
6. Rittenberg D, Schoenheimer R. Deuterium as an indicator in the study of intermediary metabolism XI. Further studies on the biological uptake of deuterium into organic substances with special references to fat and cholesterol formation. Journal of Biological Chemistry 1937; 121: 1: 235 - 253.
7. Keys A. Human atherosclerosis and the diet. Circulation 1952; 5: 115 - 118.
8. Keys A, Anderson J T, Fidanza F, Keys M H, Swahn B. Effects of diet on blood lipids in man particularly cholesterol and lipoproteins. Clinical Chemistry 1955; 1: 1: 40 - 52.
9. Kinsell L S, Partridge J, Boling L, Margen S, Michaels G, Olson F, et al. Dietary modifications and serum cholesterol and phospholipid levels. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism 1952; 12: 7: 909 - 913.
10. Hardinge M G, Stare F J. Nutritional Studies of Vegetarians: 2. Dietary and serum levels of cholesterol. Journal of Clinical Nutrition 1954; 2: 2: 82 - 88.
11. Groen J, Tjiong B K, Kamminga C E, Willebrands A F. Influence of nutrition, individual and some other factors, including various forms of stress on serum cholesterol; experiment of nine months duration in 60 normal human volunteers. Voeding 1952; 13: 556 - 587.
12. Ahrens E H Jr, Blankenhorn D H, Tsaltas, T T. Effect on Human Serum Lipids of substituting Plant for Animal Fat in Diet. Proceedings for the Society of Experimental Biology and Medicine 1954; 86: 4: 872 – 878.
13. Ahrens E H Jr, Hirsch J, Insull W Jr, Tsaltas T T, Blomstrand R, Peterson M. Dietary control of serum lipids in relation to atherosclerosis. Journal of the American Medical Association. 1957; 164: 17: 1905 – 1911.
14. Ahrens E H Jr, Hirsch J, Oette K, Farquhar J W, Stein Y. Carbohydrate induced and fat induced lipemia. Transactions of the Association of American Physicians 1961; 74: 134 – 146. Review Article.
15. Ahrens E H Jr, Insull W Jr, Blomstrand R, Hirsch J, Tsaltas T T, Peterson M L. The influence of dietary fats on serum lipid levels in Man. Lancet 1957; 272: 6976: 943 – 953.
16. Teicholz N. The big fat surprise. New York. Simon & Schuster. 2014.
17. Keys A, Anderson J T, Grande F. Prediction of serumcholesterol response of man to changes in fats in the diet. Lancet 1957; 273: 7003: 959 – 966.
18. Keys A. Atherosclerosis: A problem in newer Public Health. Journal of Mt Sinai Hospital New York 1953; 20: 2: 118 – 139.
19. Yerushalmy J, Hilleboe H E. Fat in the diet and mortality from heart disease: A methodologic note. New York State Journal of Medicine 1957; 57: 14: 2343 – 2354.
20. Mann G V. Diet and coronary heart disease. Archives of Internal Medicine 1959; 104: 921 – 929.
21. Mann G V, Shaffer R D, Anderson R S, et al. Cardiovascular disease in the Masai. Journal of Atherosclerosis Research 1964; 4: 4: 289 – 312.
22. Mann G V. Diet-Heart: End of an Era. New England Journal of Medicine 1977; 297: 12: 644 – 650.
23. Keys A, ed. Coronary Heart Disease in Seven Countries. Circulation 1970; 41 & 42: 1: Supplement 1: American Heart Association Monograph No 29: 1 – 211.
24. Ravenskov U. The cholesterol myths: exposing the fallacy that saturated fat and cholesterol cause heart disease. Washington D C: New Trends, 2000.
25. Taubes G. Good calories, bad calories: fats, carbs, and the controversial science of diet and health. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2007.
26. Sarri K, Kafatos A. The seven countries study in Crete: Olive oil, Mediterranean Diet or Fasting? Public Health Nutrition 2005; 8: 6: 666.
27. Sarri K, Linardakis M K, Bervanaki F N, Tzanakis N E, Kafatos A G. Greek orthodox fasting rituals: A hidden characteristic of the Mediterranean diet of Crete. British Journal of Nutrition 2004; 92: 2: 277 - 284.
28. Keys A, Menotti A, Aravanis C, et al. The seven countries study: 2,289 deaths in 15 years. Preventive Medicine 1984; 13: 2: 141 – 154.
29. Keys A, Menotti A, Karvonen M J, et al. The diet and 15 year death rate in the seven countries study. American Journal of Epidemiology 1986; 124: 6: 903 – 915.
30. Jolliffe N, Rinzler S H, Archer M. The anti-coronary club: including a discussion on the effects of a prudent diet on the serum cholesterol level of middle aged men. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 1959; 7: 4: 451 – 462.
31. Christakis G, Summary of the research activities of the anti-coronary club. Public Health Reports 1966; 81: 1: 64 – 70.
32. Christakis G,Rinzler S H, Archer M. Effect of the anticoronary club program on coronary heart disease risk factor status. Journal of the American Medical Association 1966; 198: 6: 597 – 604.
33. Dayton S, Pearce M L, Hashimoto S, Dixon W J, Tomiyasu U. A controlled clinical trial of a diet high in unsaturated fat in preventing complications of atherosclerosis. Circulation 1969; 40: 1: suppl 2: II – I
34. Pearce M L, Dayton S. Incidence of cancer in men on a diet high in polyunsaturated fat. Lancet 1971; 297: 7697: 464 – 467.
35. Kannel W B, Dawber T R, Kagan A, Revotskie N, Stokes J. Factors of risk in development of coronary heart disease – six years follow up experience. The Framingham Study. Annals of Internal Medicine 1961; 55: 1: 33 – 50.
36. Anderson K M, Castelli W P, Levy D. Cholesterol and mortality: 30 years of follow up from the Framingham study. Journal of the American Medical Association. 1987; 257: 16: 2176 – 2180.
37. Mann G V, Pearson G, Gordon T, Dawber T R, Lyell L, Shurtleff D. Diet and Cardiovascular disease in the Framingham study I. Measurement of dietary intake. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 1962; 11: 3: 200 – 225.
38. Malhotra S L. Geographical aspects of acute myocardial infarction in India with special reference to patterns of diet and eating. British Heart Journal 1967; 29: 3: 337 – 344.
39. Malhotra S L. Epidemiology of Ischemic heart disease in Southern India with special reference to causation. British Heart Journal 1967; 29: 6: 895 – 905.
40. Malhotra S L. Dietary factors and Ischemic heart disease. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 1971; 24: 10: 1195 – 1198.
41. Zukel W J, Lewis R H, Enterline P E. A short term community study of coronary heart disease: A preliminary report on the North Dakota study. American Journal of Public Health and the Nation's Health 1959; 49: 12: 1630 - 1639.
42. Finnegan A, Hickey N, Maurer B, Mulcahy R. Diet and coronary heart disease: Dietary analysis on 100 male patients. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 1968; 21: 2: 143 - 148.
43. Finnegan A, Hickey N, Maurer B, Mulcahy R. Diet and coronary heart disease: Dietary analysis on 50 female patients. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 1969; 22: 1: 8 - 9.
44. Gordon T, Castelli W P, Hjortland M C, Kannel W B, Dawber T R. High density lipoprotein as a protective factor against coronary heart disease: The Framingham study. American Journal of Medicine 1977; 62: 5: 707 – 714.
45. Castelli W P, Doyle J T, Gordon T, et al. HDL cholesterol and other lipids in coronary heart disease: the cooperative lipoprotein phenotyping study. Circulation 1977; 55: 5: 767 – 772.
46. Fuhrmann R. 5-best-selling-prescription meds of all time. Investopedia. September 24, 2012. Accessible at: https:/ /www.investopedia.com/financial-edge/0912/5-bestselling-prescription-meds-of-all-time.aspx (accessed 24/ 11/2017)
47. LaRosa J C. Grundy S M, Waters D D, Shear C, Barter P, Fruchart J C, et al. Intensive lipid lowering with atorvastatin in patients with stable coronary disease. New England Journal of Medicine 2005; 352: 14: 1425 – 1435.
48. Ahrens E H Jr. Carbohydrates, plasma triglycerides and coronary heart disease. Nutrition reviews 1986; 44: 2: 60 – 64.
49. Albrink M J. Triglycerides, lipoproteins, and coronary heart disease. Archives of Internal Medicine 1962; 109: 3: 345 – 359.
50. Ahrens E H Jr, Blankenhorn D H, Tsaltas T T. Effect on human serum lipids of substituting plant for animal fat in diet. Proceedings for the Society of Experimental Biology and Medicine 1954; 86: 4: 872 – 878.
51. Albrink M J. The significance of serum triglycerides. Journal of the American Dietetic Association 1963; 42: 29 – 31.
52. Mozaffarian D. Effects of dietary fats versus carbohydrates on coronary heart disease: a review of the evidence. Current Atheroscler 2005; 7: 6: 435 – 45
53. Kuipers R S, de Graff D J, Luxwolda M F, Muskiet M H, Dijck-Brouwer D A, Muskiet F A. Saturated fat, carbohydrate and cardiovascular disease. Neth J Med 2011; 69: 9: 372 – 8.
54. Mozaffarian D, Aro A, Willett W C. Health Effects of transfatty acids: experimental and observations evidence. Eur J ClinNutr 2009; 63: Suppl 2: S5 - 21. doi: 10.1038/ sj.ejcn.1602973.
55. Kummerow F A, Zhou S Q, Mahfouz M M. Effects of trans fatty acids on calcium influx into human arterial endothelial cells. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 1999; 70: 5: 832 – 838.
56. Lawson L D, Kummerow F A. B-oxidation of the coenzyme A esters of vacenic, elaidic and petroselaidic acids by rat heart mitochondria. Lipids 1979; 14: 5: 501 – 503.
57. Bendsen N T, Christensen R, Bartels E M, Astrup A. Consumption of Industrial and Ruminant trans fatty acids and risk of coronary heart disease. A systemic review and meta-analysis of cohort studies. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 2011; 65: 7: 773 – 783.
58. Ganguly R, Pierce G N. The toxicity of dietary trans fats. Food ChemToxicol 2015; 78: 170 – 6. doi: 10.1016/ j.fct.2015.02.004. Epub 2015 Feb 12.
59. Ramsden C E, Zamora D, Leelarthaepin B, Majchrzak-Hong S, Faurot K R, Suchindran C M et al. Use of dietary linoleic acid for secondary prevention of coronary heart disease and death: evaluation of recovered data from the Sydney Diet Heart Study and updated meta-analysis. BMJ 2013; 346:e8707.doi:10.1136/bmj.e8707.
60. Ramsden C E, Zamora D, Majchrzak-Hong S, Faurot K R, Broste S K, Frantz R P, et al. Re-evaluation of the traditional diet-heart hypothesis: analysis of recovered data from Minnesota Coronary Experiment (1968 – 73). BMJ 2016 Apr 12;353:i1246. doi: 10.1136/bmj.i1246.
61. Woodhill JM, Palmer AJ, Leelarthaepin B, McGilchrist C, Blacket RB. Low fat, low cholesterol diet in secondary prevention of coronary heart disease. Adv Exp Med Biol1978;109:317-30.
62. Palmer J, Leelarthaepin B, McGilchrist C, Blacket R. Coronary heart disease profile in Australian men and some factors influencing survival. Adv Exp Med Biol1977;82:115-7.
63. McGilchrist CA, Leelarthaepin B, Blacket RB. Measures on qualitative variables in coronary heart disease studies. J Chronic Dis1976;29:285-8.
64. Blacket RB, Leelarthaepin B, Palmer AJ, Woodhill JM. Coronary heart disease in young men: a study of seventy patients with a critical review of etiological factors. Aust N Z J Med 1973;3:39-62.
65. Blacket RB, Leelarthaepin B. Coronary disease in young men. Singapore Med J 1973;14:344-6.
66. Blacket RB. Diet in prevention of heart disease. Med J Australia1973;1:969-73.
67. Ramsden CE, Hibbeln JR, Majchrzak SF, Davis JM. n-6 fatty acid-specific and mixed polyunsaturate dietary interventions have different effects on CHD risk: a metaanalysis of randomised controlled trials. Br J Nutr 2010;104:1586-600.
68. Willett W C, Stampfer M. Diet and Coronary Heart Disease. In: Nutritional Epidemiology. Third edition. Willett W [ed]. Oxford. Oxford University Press. 2013; 426 – 467.
69. Masson L F, McNeill G, Avenell A. Genetic variation and the lipid response to dietary intervention: a systemic review 1’2’3. The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 2003; 77: 5: 1098 – 1111.
70. Kearns C E, Schmidt L A, Glantz S A. Sugar Industry and Coronary Heart Disease Research: A historical analysis of Internal Industry Documents. JAMA Intern Med 2016; 176: 11: 1680 – 1685.
71. DiNicolantonio J J, Lucan S C, O’Keefe J H. The evidence for saturated fat and for sugar related to coronary heart disease. Prog Cardiovasc Dis 2016; 58: 5: 464 – 472.
72. Smith T. The cholesterol-heart hypothesis: How public health advice on nutrition may be on the verge of a major paradigm shift. Alban Med J 2014; 2: 7 – 9.
Banerjee A . The Diet-Heart Hypothesis: Changing Perspectives. Perspectives in Medical Research 2018; 6 (2):4-11.